Conference insurance policy renewal
By Conference Insurance Committee on behalf of the Conference Board of Trustees | Email

Our conference-wide insurance program, underwritten by Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company, will be renewing on January 1, 2027. Our representatives at Lightwell Insurance Advisors of New York have advised us on some changes we should plan on:
An average property value increase of 2%... to cover the increased cost of construction over the last 12 months.
An average premium cost increase, for our property and liability coverage of 1.9% for the vast majority of our churches. Since this is less than the property value increases above, we should consider this a “flat” renewal. In an age where insurance costs have risen significantly over the last few years, we believe this pricing offers stability in insurance costs for our churches.
Some churches (less than 60) will see slightly higher premium cost increases due to their losses sustained over the last few years. It does not appear that any of our churches will see an increase of more than 10% however, in their premium costs, in spite of their losses. Again, we have achieved stability in our premium costs through Brotherhood Mutual.
Included in that 1.9% premium cost increase mentioned above, is a $143 increase in the costs of our conference-wide Umbrella program. We are thankful to accept this higher Umbrella pricing within the 1.9% premium cost increase for the majority of our churches and we recognize that this new umbrella cost is still very low when compared with the rest of the insurance industry.
Brotherhood Mutual will begin billings for the 2027 policy year in early December.
What can we do to help control insurance costs for all our churches?
Review building values and notify Lightwell representatives of any major construction, renovation, demolitions, or acquisitions in 2026.
Report any newly purchased vehicles, trailers, equipment, or properties.
Verify church contact and billing information before invoices are issued.
Submit outstanding claims or incident reports promptly.
To contact Lightwell Insurance advisors, reach out to our Primary Account Executive, James Nguyen at (315) 414-8631 or JNuygen@Lightwell.com.
Actual premiums will vary based on location, property characteristics, occupancy, claims history, and coverage schedules. Many religious, nonprofit, and commercial organizations continue to experience substantial premium increases nationwide. We are grateful that our partnership with Brotherhood Mutual has allowed us to maintain broad coverage and premium stability for our churches.
The Conference Board of Trustees thanks all of our churches for working so hard to manage risk and reduce insurance losses. Through all our efforts, we continue to provide coverage for our churches that exceed the limits suggested by our denominational executives, while maintaining pricing stability for all of our churches.
Let's continue to celebrate our successes in 2026 and continue our efforts in 2027.



